The 1990s were a cold, unrelenting decade for the golden gods of 70s and 80s rock. When grunge arrived like a wrecking ball, it smashed the grandeur of arena rock into dust and ushered in an era of flannel, introspection, and lo-fi sensibilities. Bands like Styx, who once soundtracked teenage dreams with power ballads, synth-fueled anthems, and concept album excess, faced a stark reality: adapt, reinvent, or become a footnote on classic rock radio.
The Divide That Made Styx Legendary (and Nearly Destroyed Them)
To understand Styx’s 90s story, you have to rewind to their roots—a time when their identity teetered between theatrical ambitions and straight-up rock energy. The tension between Dennis DeYoung and Tommy Shaw—one a visionary of Broadway-sized balladry, the other a blue-collar rock ‘n’ roller—defined their greatest hits.
Think of Styx as two bands occupying the same stage. Songs like “Come Sail Away” and “Mr. Roboto” were rich with DeYoung’s keyboard symphonics and operatic flair, while “Renegade” and “Blue Collar Man” roared with Shaw’s hard-driving rock grit. It worked in the 70s and early 80s because, at their core, Styx wrote anthems—the kind of songs that felt like both high art and good-time rock.
But that balance cracked in 1979 with Babe, DeYoung’s massive power ballad and Styx’s first No. 1 hit. A commercial triumph? Absolutely. But for Shaw, it was a warning sign. He later reflected that the band’s growing focus on ballads left him feeling sidelined, frustrated that there was ‘nothing for me to do’ on a song like Babe. ‘I wanted to rock,’ he admitted—tensions that would only grow in the years to come.
Tensions boiled over with Kilroy Was Here in 1983, a full-on rock opera that featured robots, dystopian themes, and DeYoung donning an actual robot costume on stage. It was ambitious, bizarre, and divisive—“peak DeYoung” to some, a bridge too far to others. By the mid-80s, Styx had fractured.
Reunion, Redemption, and the Edge of Survival
The 90s brought Styx back together, but not as the band fans remembered. Tommy Shaw was absent, chasing success with the arena-rock supergroup Damn Yankees, while Dennis DeYoung returned with his signature ballads and theatrical sensibilities. Edge of the Century(1990) emerged as Styx’s reunion album—this time with guitarist Glen Burtnik filling Shaw’s shoes.
It gave the band one last hit: “Show Me the Way,” a syrupy ballad that tapped into the Gulf War-era sentimentality. But Edge of the Centurywasn’t enough to sustain Styx’s place in a rapidly changing rock landscape. With the arrival of Nevermind and Ten, alternative rock obliterated any hope of Styx thriving with new music.
So where did that leave Styx? Nostalgia. Classic rock stations became the lifeline for bands like Styx, Foreigner, and Journey—groups whose hits were so baked into American rock DNA that they could survive on familiarity alone.
Why Styx Refused to Sink
While grunge took down many of their peers, Styx adapted in their own way. They didn’t chase trends, attempt a grunge makeover, or reinvent themselves like Aerosmith or U2. Instead, they leaned into their legacy—touring as a greatest-hits machine that fans still loved.
It wasn’t without drama. Styx re-entered the spotlight in 1996 when they reunited with Tommy Shaw for a tour, but the truce was short-lived. By 1999, Dennis DeYoung was out, replaced by Lawrence Gowan, a younger, flashier keyboardist who could replicate DeYoung’s sound while injecting fresh energy into their live shows.
The choice to press forward without DeYoung was controversial—fans were split between loyalty to the original lineup and excitement about seeing Styx “rock” again with Shaw at the helm. But what the 90s proved was that Styx could survive—not by thriving creatively, but by enduring.
The Styx Effect: Songs That Outlast Time
What makes Styx still matter? Songs like “Renegade,” “Come Sail Away,” and “Blue Collar Man” aren’t just classic rock staples—they’re part of America’s musical DNA. Listen to the pulse of “Renegade” and you’ll hear the seeds of 80s metal. Strip down “Lady” and it’s a masterclass in power ballad craftsmanship.
Styx’s ability to write memorable songs transcended genre trends. Their music, much like their career, blended ambition with blue-collar heart—a mix that feels timeless even when it’s of its time.
The Final Verdict
Did Styx thrive, adapt, or fade into nostalgic obscurity during the 90s? It’s not an easy call. Some argue they merely stayed afloat—content to sail on the strength of their greatest hits. Others see their survival as proof of a legacy built to endure, even as their creative spark flickered in the face of grunge and alternative rock dominance.
But the story doesn’t end there. While the 90s were a turning point, Styx proved they still had fuel in the tank. The band continues releasing new music into the 2000s and beyond, albums like Cyclorama, The Mission, and Crash Of The Crown finding their way onto setlists alongside timeless hits. Their live shows—a mix of fresh material and fan favorites—demonstrated a band that refused to rely solely on nostalgia, even as they leaned into their legacy.
The band’s fractured lineup, the push and pull between Dennis DeYoung’s grandiose vision and Tommy Shaw’s rock grit, and their decision to carry on through a shifting musical landscape—it all leaves room for debate. Were they a band who lost their edge, or a group that embraced evolution while staying true to who they were?
To hear the full breakdown of Styx’s 90s journey—including Tim, Jay, and Chip making their cases and weighing listener insights—check out the latest discussion. Was Styx’s survival a triumph, a compromise, or something in between? Listen and decide for yourself.
Songs in this Episode
Intro - Show Me The Way (from Edge of the Century)
7:40 - Blue Collar Man (Long Nights) (from Pieces of Eight)
28:42 - Suite Madame Blue (from Equinox)
38:56 - Back To Chicago (from Edge of the Century)
41.57 - All In A Day's Work (from Edge of the Century)
58:57 - What Have They Done to You (from Brave New World)
Outro - Everything Is Cool (from Brave New World)
Your Voice Shapes the Show
At Dig Me Out, we’re always pushing into new territory, trying out fresh ideas and concepts that bring fans deeper into the music they love. Your input drives what we do.
By becoming a paid subscriber, you’re helping us stay independent and keep the music front and center. And if you want a direct role in choosing the artists and albums we explore, consider joining the DMO Union on Patreon. Your suggestions, votes, and insights shape the show, ensuring the voices of true fans are always heard.
Share this post